Shifting from pay-as-you-go to individual retirement accounts: A path to a sustainable pension system

Download

• Paper
• Online appendix
• Working paper version

Abstract

With aging demographics and generous pension programs, the sustainability of the pay-as-you-go (PAYG) public pension system has been often questioned and has motivated policymakers to enact reforms in many countries. Although mandatory funded Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs) appear to be a solution to this unsustainable system, existing reforms usually take place within the PAYG system by reducing pension benefits. This paper evaluates the effects of PAYG reforms as well as reforms that switch to the IRA system. Our analysis shows that PAYG reforms outperform IRA reforms in many aspects. In fact, PAYG reforms achieve higher GDP and yield higher welfare in the long run. The transition to the steady state is also found to be less volatile for PAYG reforms. While PAYG generally places a larger burden on future generations, the positive welfare effect of cross-subsidization dominates the welfare loss. Our findings may explain why pension reform is a controversial issue in most countries and why we rarely observe a shift to the IRA system.

Citation

Lin, Hsuan-Chih, Atsuko Tanaka, and Po-Shyan Wu. “Shifting from Pay-as-You-Go to Individual Retirement Accounts: A Path to a Sustainable Pension System.” Journal of Macroeconomics 69 (September 2021): 103329. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmacro.2021.103329.

@article{linShiftingPayasyougoIndividual2021,
  title = {Shifting from Pay-as-You-Go to Individual Retirement Accounts: {{A}} Path to a Sustainable Pension System},
  shorttitle = {Shifting from Pay-as-You-Go to Individual Retirement Accounts},
  author = {Lin, Hsuan-Chih and Tanaka, Atsuko and Wu, Po-Shyan},
  date = {2021-09},
  journaltitle = {Journal of Macroeconomics},
  shortjournal = {Journal of Macroeconomics},
  volume = {69},
  pages = {103329},
  issn = {01640704},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jmacro.2021.103329},
  url = {https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0164070421000355},
  urldate = {2025-10-15},
  langid = {english}
}}